Red Team My Idea

Red team this idea. Your job is to find every weakness, risk, and failure mode. Be specific and direct — don't soften the feedback.

For each issue you find, provide:

1. The specific weakness or risk
2. Why it matters (potential impact)
3. How likely it is to occur
4. A concrete suggestion to mitigate it

After the critique, give an overall viability assessment on a scale of 1-10 with a brief justification.

The idea: {{idea}}